Towns
- All Towns (1077)
- Amaganset (5)
- Aquebogue (36)
- Baiting Hollow (16)
- Baldwin (1)
- Bayport (1)
- Bellport (1)
- Bohemia (1)
- Brentwood (1)
- Bridgehampton (1)
- Brooklyn (2)
- Calverton (6)
- Center Moriches (3)
- Centereach (7)
- Coram (10)
- Cutchogue (60)
- Deer Park (1)
- E. Quogue (33)
- East Hampton (31)
- East Marion (21)
- East Moriches (5)
- Eastport (4)
- Flanders (14)
- Forest Hills (1)
- Greenport (47)
- Hampton Bays (43)
- Hauppauge (1)
- Holbrook (2)
- Holtsville (1)
- Huntington Sta (1)
- Jamesport (25)
- Kew Garden Hills (1)
- Lake Grove (2)
- Laurel (14)
- Lynbrook (1)
- Manorville (5)
- Mastic (1)
- Mastic Beach (1)
- Mattituck (46)
- Medford (4)
- Middle Island (6)
- Miller Place (25)
- Montauk (9)
- Mt. Sinai (36)
- N. Babylon (1)
- Nassau Point (1)
- New Hyde Park (1)
- New Suffolk (2)
- Nissequogue (3)
- Old Field (1)
- Orient (22)
- Out Of Area Town (12)
- Park Slope (1)
- Patchogue (1)
- Peconic (14)
- Poquott (1)
- Port Jefferson (8)
- Pt.Jefferson Sta (14)
- Quogue (31)
- Remsenburg (15)
- Ridge (8)
- Riverhead (85)
- Rocky Point (18)
- Ronkonkoma (1)
- S. Jamesport (3)
- S. Setauket (1)
- Sag Harbor (5)
- Sagaponack (1)
- Selden (3)
- Setauket (2)
- Shelter Island (16)
- Shirley (2)
- Shoreham (8)
- Sound Beach (14)
- Southampton (23)
- Southold (113)
- St. James (1)
- Stony Brook (1)
- Wading River (23)
- Water Mill (1)
- West Islip (1)
- Westhampton (32)
- Westhampton Bch (55)
Select Town(s):
- Amaganset
- Aquebogue
- Baiting Hollow
- Baldwin
- Bayport
- Bellport
- Bohemia
- Brentwood
- Bridgehampton
- Brooklyn
- Calverton
- Center Moriches
- Centereach
- Coram
- Cutchogue
- Deer Park
- E. Quogue
- E. Setauket
- East Hampton
- East Marion
- East Moriches
- Eastport
- Farmingville
- Flanders
- Forest Hills
- Greenport
- Hampton Bays
- Hauppauge
- Holbrook
- Holtsville
- Huntington Sta
- Jamesport
- Kew Garden Hills
- Lake Grove
- Laurel
- Lynbrook
- Manorville
- Mastic
- Mastic Beach
- Mattituck
- Medford
- Middle Island
- Miller Place
- Montauk
- Mt. Sinai
- N. Babylon
- Nassau Point
- New Hyde Park
- New Suffolk
- Nissequogue
- Old Field
- Orient
- Out Of Area Town
- Park Slope
- Patchogue
- Peconic
- Poquott
- Port Jefferson
- Pt.Jefferson Sta
- Quogue
- Remsenburg
- Ridge
- Riverhead
- Rocky Point
- Ronkonkoma
- S. Jamesport
- S. Setauket
- Sag Harbor
- Sagaponack
- Selden
- Setauket
- Shelter Island
- Shelter Island Heights
- Shirley
- Shoreham
- Sound Beach
- Southampton
- Southold
- St. James
- Stony Brook
- Wading River
- Water Mill
- West Islip
- Westhampton
- Westhampton Bch
- 11964
Choose Criteria:
Show Only:
- Waterfront
- Pool
- Open Houses
- Last 7 Days
Properties For Sale - Shelter Island
Click listings for more information
- 9 Westmoreland Dr
Shelter Island
Residential -
$2,900,000
6 Bed /3.5 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Open House 05/25 1:30Pm-2:30PmStately, Historic, 2.02 Acre Waterfront Tudor Estate, 'Primrose Cottag More»
- 12A Sunshine Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$1,395,000
3 Bed /2.5 Bath -
Debra Von Brook Binder
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
3,338 Sq. Ft. Proposed New Home Will Be Ready For Your Arrival For Nex More»
- 12 Locust Woods Dr
Shelter Island
Residential -
$1,299,000
4 Bed /4.5 Bath -
Elizabeth Gilpin
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Lovely Greek Revival,Situated On A Beautiful Parcel Backs Onto A Prese More»
- 13 Locust Woods Dr
Shelter Island
Residential -
$975,000
6 Bed /4.5 Bath -
Christine Beckwith
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
This Beautifully Designed 6Br 4.5Ba Victorian Sits On Top Of A Hill In More»
- 16 Saint Marys Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$875,000
4 Bed /2 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Open House 05/25 10Am-11:30AmCo-Exclusive. Quaint & Cozy Cape On 2.2 Acre Property With Bonus Build More»
- 6 Hay Beach Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$799,000
3 Bed /2 Bath -
Margaret Colligan
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Beautiful Acre In Desireable Hay Beach With Winter Water Peek! Propert More»
- 7 Margarets Dr
Shelter Island
Residential -
$795,000
3 Bed /2 Bath -
Raymond Lord
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Enjoy The Sunny South Facing Living Room With Cathedral Ceiling That O More»
- 29 Terry Dr
Shelter Island
Residential -
$650,000
4 Bed /2 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Lovely Raised Ranch In Harborview Area With Private Beach And Mooring More»
- 19 Shelterlands Path
Shelter Island
Residential -
$645,000
3 Bed /2.5 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Newly Reduced, Motivated Sellers! A House For All Seasons. Across From More»
- 54 N Menantic Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$599,000
4 Bed /2.5 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Open House 05/25 12Pm-1PmA 2.68 Acre Property With Room For Horses, Barn, Pool & Tennis, Hosts More»
- 14 Hillside Dr
Shelter Island
Residential -
$579,900
4 Bed /2 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
This Roomy 4Br/2Ba Home, W/15X30 Sunroom Comes With The Hilo Shores Co More»
- 29 Saint Marys Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$539,000
0 Bed /0.55 Bath -
Nicholas Planamento
Town And Country Real Estate
Formerly Saltaire Nursery / Shelter Island Gardens This 4 Acre Lot W S More»
- 8 W Thomas St
Shelter Island
Residential -
$495,000
3 Bed /1 Bath -
Susan Cincotta
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Private With Berm And Gate Leading To Bucolic Setting. This Charming 3 More»
- 14 Sylvan Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$489,000
3 Bed /2 Bath -
Margaret Colligan
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Lovely Property With Great Potential, This Home Sits At The End Of A Q More»
- 10 Bowditch Rd
Shelter Island
Residential -
$485,000
3 Bed /2 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Open House 05/25 10Am-11:30AmQuaint, Cozy Cape Nestled In A Wooded, Scenic Lot. Convenient To Stabl More»
- 82 Smith St
Shelter Island
Residential -
$449,000
1 Bed /1 Bath -
Linda McCarthy
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
Open House 05/25 10Am-11:30AmThis Adorable Cottage Is Conveniently Located Near Beach, Boating & To More»
